Comparison Tool

Subcontractor vs Employee Calculator Australia

Enter your employee salary and instantly compare take-home pay, super, leave entitlements, and the hourly rate you'd need to charge as an independent subbie.

Subcontractor vs Employee Calculator

Employee Salary & Benefits

$
Enter your base annual full-time salary package.
%
%

Subcontractor vs Employee Guide for Tradies

What's the Real Difference Between a Subcontractor and an Employee?

Many new subbies make the mistake of thinking that subcontracting just means a higher hourly rate. In reality, it is a completely different legal and financial setup. A permanent employee has income tax withheld automatically, receives 12.0% employer superannuation, and receives paid annual/sick leave. A subcontractor operates under their own Australian Business Number (ABN), acts as a separate business, and must invoice clients for payment.

As a subbie, if you don't work, you don't get paid. You have no sick days, no annual holidays, and no public holidays. This is why subcontractors must charge 30% to 50% more than employee rates to cover self-funded buffers.

How the ATO Decides If You're an Employee or Contractor

The ATO uses a multi-factor test to determine if you are a genuine subcontractor or if your arrangement is actually "sham contracting." The key criteria include:

  • Control Over Work: Employees are directed on how, where, and when to work. Subcontractors control how the job gets done and schedule their own hours.
  • Tools & Vehicle: Subcontractors own, maintain, and transport all their own tools and work utes. You can claim work travel using our Cents Per KM Calculator.
  • Financial Risk: Subcontractors bear the risk of profit or loss on each job and must rectify faulty work at their own expense.
  • Ability to Delegate: Subcontractors are free to hire assistants or delegate work to other subbies.

Financial Comparison: Employee vs Subcontractor

Entitlement / ExpenseAs EmployeeAs Subcontractor (Subbie)
Superannuation12.0% paid by employerSelf-funded (check Subcontractor Super Calculator)
Annual Leave4 weeks (20 days) paid holidaysUnpaid (self-funded buffer required)
Sick & Carer's Leave10 days paid personal leaveUnpaid (income stops if sick/injured)
Public Holidays11-13 paid holidays per yearUnpaid
Workers Comp & InsuranceCovered by employerSelf-funded (Public Liability & Income Protection)
Tools & VehicleProvided or allowance paidPaid entirely by subbie
Tax & InvoicingAutomated PAYG taxSelf-managed invoicing via Invoice Generator

Example: Employee on $75,000 vs Going Subbie

To match a standard $75,000 employee salary package, here is how a subcontractor rate is built from the ground up:

  1. Step 1: Total Employee Package Value — $75,000 base + $9,000 super (12%) + $1,500 Workers Comp = $85,500 true cost.
  2. Step 2: Add Subcontractor Expenses — Ute running costs ($6,000), tools ($2,000), insurances ($2,000), admin ($2,500) = $12,500.
  3. Step 3: Add 15% Profit Margin — ($85,500 + $12,500) × 15% = $14,700 profit buffer. Total Target = $112,700.
  4. Step 4: Calculate Billable Hours — 48 weeks × 5 days = 240 days. Less 10 sick days and 11 public holidays = 219 days × 8 hrs = 1,752 hrs. Less 20% non-billable travel/quoting = 1,402 billable hours.
  5. Step 5: Minimum Subbie Hourly Rate — $112,700 ÷ 1,402 billable hrs = $80.38 / hr (ex GST) or $88.42 / hr (inc GST).

Trade-by-Trade Subcontractor Rate Benchmarks (Australia 2026)

Below is a realistic guide comparing average employee salaries with the minimum subcontractor charge-out rates required in Australian metropolitan areas:

TradeAvg Employee SalaryMin Subbie Rate (ex GST)Min Subbie Rate (inc GST)
Electrician (Sparky)$85,000 / yr$92 – $115 / hr$101 – $126.50 / hr
Plumber$82,000 / yr$88 – $110 / hr$96.80 – $121 / hr
Carpenter (Chippy)$78,000 / yr$82 – $102 / hr$90.20 – $112.20 / hr
Painter$70,000 / yr$75 – $92 / hr$82.50 – $101.20 / hr
Tiler$75,000 / yr$80 – $98 / hr$88 – $107.80 / hr
Bricklayer / Concreter$76,000 / yr$84 – $105 / hr$92.40 – $115.50 / hr

Hidden Costs of Going Solo as a Subcontractor

  • Unbilled Travel Time: Driving between jobs eats up 5-10 billable hours per week.
  • Public Liability & Income Protection: Essential coverage costs between $2,500 and $5,000 per year.
  • Bookkeeping & Accounting Fees: Software like Xero plus end-of-year tax filing costs around $2,000 annually.

Tax and GST Obligations for Subcontractors

Subcontractors must manage their own ATO tax obligations. Set aside 25% to 35% of every invoice for tax and PAYG instalments using our Sole Trader Tax Calculator. If turnover exceeds $75,000, you must register for GST and lodge quarterly BAS returns using our GST Calculator.

While subcontractors don't have Fair Work Award protections, you have significant legal rights under Australian commercial law:

  • Security of Payment Acts: State laws (e.g. Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act in NSW/VIC/QLD) give subbies strict rights to prompt payment and rapid adjudication if a principal contractor refuses to pay an invoice.
  • Unfair Contract Terms: Under Australian Consumer Law, unfair terms in small business contracts (such as one-sided termination or unreasonable penalty clauses) can be declared void.
  • Right to Delegate: Genuine contractors have the right to subcontract tasks unless explicitly restricted in writing.

Checklist Before Going Solo as a Subcontractor

  1. Apply for an ABN: Free online application via ABR (abr.gov.au).
  2. Organise Insurances: Get Public Liability ($10M min) and Income Protection before stepping on site.
  3. Open a Business Bank Account: Keep personal and subbie business funds strictly separate.
  4. Set Up Invoicing: Prepare professional tax invoice templates using our Invoice Generator.
  5. Setup Tax Savings Account: Automatically transfer 25%-30% of invoice payments for ATO tax and BAS.
  6. Setup Super Fund: Open a complying super fund and set up automated monthly contributions.

When to Stay an Employee vs Going Subbie

Stay employed if you prefer steady paychecks, employer-paid super, and zero admin hassles. Switch to subcontracting if you want higher earning potential, schedule independence, own your tools/ute, and are ready to run an ABN business cleanly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything Australian tradies ask about hourly rates